Friday, October 24, 2014
Type-1 and Obstructive Sleep Apnea
A reader of this blog asked me what I knew about the relationship between Obstructive Sleep Apnea (OSA) and Type-1 Diabetes. I didn't know anything, but over the last few weeks, I've been looking through the research. There is not a lot, but what there is, I've summarized here.
The sound track for this posting is Bon Jovi's I'll Sleep When I'm Dead:
This is an area where it is important not to mix up type-2 and type-1 diabetes, and to remember that people who say "diabetes" almost always mean "type-2 diabetes". One of the more common causes of OSA is being overweight, and this is also one of the more common causes of type-2 diabetes (although in neither case is it the only cause). The result is that OSA is highly correlated with type-2 diabetes.
However, there has been a little research on type-1 diabetes and Obstructive Sleep Apnea (OSA), and that is what I'm focusing on here.
But first, a little background on OSA:
Question 1: How common is OSA?
Simple Answer: about 5% of the general population, and about twice that in people with T1D.
Detailed Answer: The overall rate is about 4% [r2] or 5.7% [r4] of the population, but the rate for people who have T1D is about 10% [r3] or 12.7% [r4]. One study [r6] found that sleep apneas were much more common in type-1 diabetics, than in type-2 diabetics. Study [r8] found high levels of sleep apneas in people with type-1 diabetes, but had no comparison group.
Question 2: Is OSA a danger sign for people who have T1D?
The [r4] study found no connection between sleep issues and HbA1c numbers. But [r5] found that patients' poor glycemic control and worse apneas were correlated (but no way to tell which caused the other, or if they were both caused by something else entirely). The "Sleep and Glucose Regulation in Youth With Type 1 Diabetes Mellitus" study [r7] is clearly based on the idea that bad sleep results in worse BG control. Their data shows a clear correlation, but again,I don't see a causal direction. Although it seems reasonable to me to think that if you BG was out of range, that would cause sleeping problems, rather than the other way around.
Question 3: Is OSA an early warning signal of T1D?
While there is no question that OSA can be an early warning sign of type-2 diabetes, I was not able to find any studies suggesting that it was an early warning sign for type-1.
Question 4: Does OSA cause T1D?
Question 5: Does T1D cause OSA?
I could not find any research on these questions.
There is only one related clinical trial currently running. They are comparing people who have type-1 diabetes to those without, and are investigating relative rates of OSA, type-1 issues which might cause OSA, and OSA impacts on complications of type-1. The study includes 145 people, and is expected to be completed in Sept. 2016. They are recruiting in Paris, France.
Clinical Trial Record: http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT01935765
There is another small study at the University of Arizona, where students with type-1 will be asked to extend their sleeping hours.
Clinical Trial Record: http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct2/show/NCT01739712
My basic conclusion from all this, is that there is very little research in this area. Based on what we have, it looks like OSA is much more common in people who have type-1 diabetes than in others, and maybe even more common in people with type-1 than type-2 diabetes. This is a major change in perspective, since OSA is traditionally associated (in people's minds) with type-2 diabetes. Unfortunately, almost nothing else is known about the causality or effects of OSA in people who have type-1 diabetes.
[r5] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/10907113 (this study uses the term "insulin dependant diabetes", but they are clearly studying children, so I'm assuming they are type-1)
[r7] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/22215921 mass media report here:
http://www.medpagetoday.com/Endocrinology/Diabetes/30460 and clinical trial record here:
publicjoshualevy at gmail dot com
All the views expressed here are those of Joshua Levy, and nothing here is official JDRF, JDCA, or Tidepool news, views, policies or opinions. My daughter has type-1 diabetes and participates in clinical trials, which might be discussed here. My blog contains a more complete non-conflict of interest statement. Thanks to everyone who helps with the blog.
Posted by Joshua Levy